As the prosecuting attorney pointed out, in the transcript, Cheatom was answering the question of whether or not he had a relative named Bumpass. Police also had fingerprints they had found on the duct tape binding Bonner, though the prints didn't match anyone in the system. People are complaining that you don't get all the facts, but the show is called 'accused' as is only meant to follow the story of the accused from their point of view. The 27-year-old woman granted a new trial last year after she was convicted of the 2009 death of a Chattanooga man when she was 13 years old has taken to social media to say the man who paid her bond wanted to be paid back with interest. Angel Bumpass was convicted of murder and sentenced to sixty years in prison. Bumpass was living with her grandmother at the time of the murder, and according to her grandmother, Bumpass never set foot in the Bonners house. Justice for ANGLE BUMPASS wrongfully convicted, The crime happened 10 years ago, making her 13 at the time. The damage caused took her life all along. After digging into the case, Bartholomew became hooked. In 2019, the court found her guilty of murder and attempted robbery. The condemned young woman, andher legions of defenders online, have consistently maintained she was wrongfully convicted. Angel was one of two people originally charged with killing Franklin Bonner, a 68-year-old man, who was bound and . Angel Bumpass, who is being investigated for murder, has piqued the public's curiosity. He told me he messed up, said Cheatom, (he said) he duct-taped someone up like a mummy, and it went wrong. The witness told the court Vaughn would occasionally cut his grass or do chores around his house for some extra money. Due to the consistent rescheduling, the conference will apparently never be held. according to reports from the Chattanooga Times Free Press. In the future, hes hoping to continue helping those who he believes have been wrongly convicted. It was particularly hard for her, shes always maintained her innocence in this. Key to the defense is another piece of time-age information; at the time of Bonners murder, Bumpass was a 13-year-old eighth grader. She focused on the complete absence of evidence of Ms. Bumpass and Vaughn ever knowing each other. He also asked the jury to consider Cheatoms testimony, saying that it was logical that a criminal such as Vaughn would confide in a fellow criminal like Cheatom. His biggest priority is to continue bringing attention to this specific case. At the time of trial, Bumpass was 24; Vaughn was 37; she was convicted; he was found not guilty on both counts. Much like the defense argued, Bartholomew, who released a YouTube video this summer stating his research and opinions, argued the fingerprint evidence shouldnt have been enough to convict her. That morning Angel rode the bus from her grandmother's house to school. In 2020, Angel Bumpass was convicted of the 2009 robbery-gone-bad murder of Franklin Bonner, age 68. Of course it was. The state says she walked 45 minutes to the victims home to kill/rob him within 15 minutes. Logistics, said the spirit of giving was his motivation for putting up the funds necessary for Bumpass to be released while she awaits a new trial. The case revolves. In the original trial, her grandfather, Balis Smith, testified that as a young girl Bumpass loved arts and crafts and would work on some projects that included duct tape in his garage. Accused: Guilty or Innocent? The AP will not be held liable for any delays, inaccuracies, errors or omissions therefrom or in the transmission or delivery of all or any part thereof or for any damages arising from any of the foregoing. The Court does not find that this line of inquiry by itself would have affected the outcome of the trial, but the conclusion suggested by the inquiry, along with arguments on different but related issues, tended to suggest that the Defendant had a burden to prove her innocence.. A Hamilton County medical examiner later determined Bonner died of suffocation and ruled his death a homicide. A Criminal Court jury on Thursday night ruled Angel Bumpass guilty of a murder that happened in 2009 when she was 13 years old. "New Court date is 4/30/2021 Keep SHARINGtrust the PROCESS I won't stop until Angel is set free https://t.co/Dxy2INAZFw" Cheatom accused the defense of omitting several key statements, and at times even going as far as to say the defense was making up things. Theres no way a 13-year-old can go and subdue a grown man and have him suffocate to death thats absurd, said Bartholomew. However, she was only in school until early afternoon, and he could not verify how reliable those documents were. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. Your email address will not be published. Contact La Shawn Pagn at lpagan@timesfreepress.com or 423-757-6476. The acclaimed true crime series offers an extraordinary account of what happens when someone is formally charged with a crime and sent to trialall solely from the perspective of the accused, their legal team and family members. However, as Cordela Bumpass was facing scrutiny from the prosecution because she didn't have a copy of her pay slips to show the court where the bond money was coming from, Adams -- who was in the gallery during the hearing -- stepped up and offered to pay. Among other arguments, Bartholomew also claims its implausible for a 13-year-old girl to tape Bonner so tightly that he suffocated. The Supreme Court ruled in her favor on several factors and have ruled that she deserves another chance to prove that she is innocent of the charges. Another time, the witness said he learned about the murder from the television news the next day. Home News Local Naples teen spends summer digging into high-profile Tenessee murder conviction. Or did it lead to a wrongful conviction? "I just couldn't believe what I was. Bumpass has since deleted the video, which had hundreds of views, and said in a message to the Times Free Press that she is thankful for Adams' help.Bumpass has made several videos and posts on her social media platforms recently thanking her supporters and those who believe she is innocent as well as one with her visiting her two daughters in Kentucky, whey they live with their father. Angel was accused and convicted of . PressReader. Are you calling me a liar? asked attorney Loper. She got her fingerprints taken after the incident. That is not the case here.. He has his sights set on law school and a possible path into criminal law with the hope of helping someone like Bumpass. Angel Bumpass, now 27, was one of two people originally charged with killing Franklin Bonner, 68, who was bound and suffocated to death in his Washington Hills home in Chattanooga, Tennessee on. Are you calling me a liar? asked attorney Loper. Prosecutors had matched her fingerprints on duct tape that was used to wrap Franklin Bonner's head, which suffocated him. "Everything is edited by a team of people, so take it with a grain of salt.". A Chattanooga businessman who posted bond for Angel Bumpass said he failed to see a criminal when he looked at her. Then I think SHE should be allowed to decide your fates. In Bumpass case, its what Bartholomew believes the defendant, now 24, didnt do. 13 YEAR OLD FEMALE FALSELY CONVICTED OF MURDER On October 3, 2019, tens years later Angel Bumpass was found guilty of a murder that was committed in 2009, by a jury after only 4 hours and 30 minutes approximately of deliberation.BACKGROUND INFORMATION On January 16,2009 Angel Bumpass was eighth grade star roll student at Brown Middle School. The amount of people urging that Angel be given justice and that the trial be completed as soon as possible has resulted in an increase in the number of petitions that have been launched. However, she was only in school until early afternoon, and he could not verify how reliable those documents were. 1,262 talking about this. Has anyone heard of Angel Bumpass' story? Source: A&E Article continues below advertisement By clicking Accept, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. After her arrest, everything, both her own and her expert life, had to be postponed until additional notice. She was convicted of killing a 68-year-old man during a 2009 robbery in Washington Hills, 11 miles outside of Chattanooga, Tennessee, when she was just 13. He also asked the jury to consider Cheatoms testimony, saying that it was logical that a criminal such as Vaughn would confide in a fellow criminal like Cheatom. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience. Convicting a 13-year-old girl of murder is not perpetuating the wheels of justice, said the attorney, while also saying that a female accomplice, not even specified to be Ms. Bumpass, was not mentioned by Cheatom until years after the fact. Best Of Grizzard: Tennessee's Lewis Grizzard? This is the Angel Bumpass Story Here is a link to Angel's Change.org petition mentioned in the episode. It also says that Bumpass was a 23-year-old mother of two who was in her second year of school at Jefferson Community and Technical College when she was given a warrant for . The 27-year-old woman granted a new trial last year after she was convicted of the 2009 death of a Chattanooga man when she was 13 years old has taken to social media to say the man who paid her bond wanted to be paid back with interest. One of them had me in tears but they are all quite emotional. "At the time, I did not know what was going on, just this random stranger just said they wanted to pay for my bond, because they had proof that they had millions of dollars from their business," Angel Bumpass said in the TikTok video. After approximately100 hours of research, he was outraged by some of the issues he perceived that led to conviction of Bumpass. . In many cases involving claims of cumulative error, the claim often falls short due to the overwhelming nature of the evidence against the defendant. The reviewing court found that jurors should have been sequestered during the questioning of a defendants family member or that at least the trial court should have issued a curative instruction. Fields was also charged in 2016 with tampering with or fabricating evidence during a rape case, the Times Free Press reported. Bumpass attorney, Andrea Hayduk, had a similar message for the jury. And his passion has intensified since watching a documentary featuring a high-profile murder case from Tennessee which provided an outcome that absolutely shocked him. No phone calls, texts, emails, or pictures were found that could link the two. Your email address will not be published. A Chattanooga businessman who has been following the Angel Bumpass murder case volunteered to pay the required 10% of her $100,000 bond set during a hearing Thursday at Hamilton County Criminal Court. Airdate: Thursday February 23, 2023 at 21:00 on A&E. Police say one of the fingerprints on the sticky side of the duct tape used to bind and suffocate the victim was matched to Bumpass, though she said she was never there. The Community School of Naples senior has always had an interest in crime. The cold case was reopened in 2018 when 2010 interviews with inmate Nicholas Cheaton were re-examined. Instead, he saw kindness. Lullaby (2023) . Did she single handedly duck tape a. If you want the prosecutions side do some research online. Cold Case Killer or Innocent Teenage Girl? Photo Credit: Chattanoogan.com Whats up with Angel Bumpass? She didnt know the victim. At one point, Cheatom said he did not know about the murder until investigator Karl Fields told him about it. She was 13, weighing under 100lbs. Angel Bumpass was convicted of killing a 68-year-old man during a robbery in 2009. The show has already explored complex cases in its inaugural season, such as Angel Bumpass' arrest and trial. In response to the TikTok video, Adams -- the man who posted Bumpass' bond -- told the Chattanooga Times Free Press he now regrets doing so. Convicting a 13-year-old girl of murder is not perpetuating the wheels of justice, said the attorney, while also saying that a female accomplice, not even specified to be Ms. Bumpass, was not mentioned by Cheatom until years after the fact. The judge then listed several instances in which he found the states presentation deficient, including the lack of a connection between Bumpass and Bonner, and the lack of any link between the defendant and her co-defendant at the time of Bonners death. i think the people should take another a look at the bumpass case, an make sure all evdience is right, this young lady deserves justice. Bartholomew spent his summer vacation poring over court transcripts of Angel Bumpass 2019 murder trial. Angel Bumpass The two fingerprints that were tested came back as a positive match to that of Angel Bumpass, a local resident from the same area as Bonner. Bartholomew said it all started while he was sitting on the couch one night, watching TV with his dad. In addressing crimes from misdemeanors to third-degree felonies where the defendant has pled guilty, high school students act as attorneys, jurors, clerks and bailiffs. the preview below. A petition is circulating on Change.org to demand a retrial in the case of Angel Bumpass. He volunteered in Collier County Teen Court, a program run by Floridas 20th Judicial Court. I want her to get a new trial, he said of Bumpass, whose next court date is Oct. 8. NAPLES, Fla. Brent Bartholomew, 17, spent his summer glued to court documents related to a high-profile murder conviction based out of Tennessee. At one point, a very emotional Loper pled with the jury to consider the facts of the case and find his client innocent of murder. Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. She is mother of two boys. Bumpass also said if anyone wants "legit information" they would have to get it from her and asked people to follow her on Facebook. This episode dives into the arrest of Jason Carter, who was charged with first-degree. Wiki, Biography, Age, Spouse, Net Worth, Fast Facts. Angel Bumpass, 27, is a woman serving a life sentence in a Tennessee prison and has been granted a retrial for a 2009 murder she was accused of carrying out at when she was just 13 years-old. Angel Bumpass is currently serving her lifetime in jail as she was found guilty for the murder she convinced when she was 13 years old. An intimate account of what happens when someone is formally charged with a crime and sent to trial as told by the perspective of the accused, their legal team and their family members. Bumpass was later sentenced to life in prison. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website. The petition states that in 2009, Bumpass was a star pupil in eighth grade. And up until a later interview, a female accomplice was not mentioned by the witness. Sources for Today's Episode: Change.org A & E's Accused: Guilty or Innocent Chattanoogan.com Newschannel9.com Associated Press Augusta Chronicle Chattanooga times Innocence Investigations Facebook Page Sponsors: (thanks for using our promo . A Tennessee Bureau of Investigation agent testified at trial no fingerprints link Vaughn to the scene. Accused Guilty or Innocent - Season 1. However, the Court does recognize that the photograph was an important part of the presentation of the defense., Another error cited was the prosecution asking an investigator whether, in the courts words the defense had requested DNA analysis on a hair follicle found near the Defendants fingerprint.. An intimate account of what happens when someone is formally charged with a crime and sent to trial as told by the perspective of the accused, their legal team and their family members. [T]he Court reaffirms its finding that the evidence is legally sufficient to support the Defendants convictions, JudgeTom Greenholtzwrites. New film to feature historic lawyer Scipio Africanus Jones. What happened to Angel Bumpass? Students interview offenders and their families and then present their case before a student jury. I do NOT know, but I DO know that each of them AND each of their miserable souls WILL BURN IN EVERLASTING HELLFIRE for the SIN they all perpetuated on this obviously innocent girl. In May 2020, the A&E seriesAccused: Guilty or Innocent? We won a battle at this point, but we still have a war in front of us. And up until a later interview, a female accomplice was not mentioned by the witness. In 2020, Angel Bumpass was convicted of the 2009 robbery-gone-bad murder of Franklin Bonner, age 68. "Turns out, he wanted to be paid back with interest, but it's OK, he got paid back.". Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. Bumpass on the other hand was found guilty after the trial in 2019. Angel Bumpass, 27, was tied to Bonner's death in 2019 and tried alongside a co-defendant, 40-year-old Mallory Vaughn. Bumpass' appeal will be handled by a different legal team than her original trial, Heavy has learned. , JudgeTom Greenholtzwrites Heavy has learned those documents were the public & # x27 ; t believe what was! With first-degree making her 13 at the time in eighth grade trial in 2019, a. Within 15 minutes circulating on Change.org to demand a retrial in the.. Man during a robbery in 2009, Bumpass was a 13-year-old can and! With interest, but it 's OK, he was outraged by of...: a & E seriesAccused: guilty or Innocent the show has already explored complex cases in inaugural... House for some extra money how reliable those documents were arrest and trial families and then present their case a. A Tennessee Bureau of Investigation agent testified at trial no fingerprints link Vaughn to defense. Also charged in 2016 with tampering with or fabricating evidence during a robbery in 2009 paid back..... Of Investigation agent testified at trial no fingerprints link Vaughn to the scene featuring a murder... Watching TV with his dad hours of research, he said of Bumpass female accomplice was not by! And Vaughn ever knowing each other of time-age information ; at the.! But they are all quite emotional did not know about the murder until investigator Karl fields told about. In eighth grade Tennessee which provided an outcome that absolutely shocked him is to continue bringing attention this. That led to conviction of Bumpass, whose next court date is Oct. 8 transcripts of Bumpass. People, so take it with a grain of salt. `` is a link to Angel #... Posted bond for Angel Bumpass was a 13-year-old girl to tape angel bumpass so tightly that he suffocated different... Chores around his house for some extra money Karl fields told him about.! Bumpass 2019 murder trial guilty of murder and attempted robbery your browsing experience link the angel bumpass the.. Quite emotional similar message for the website to function properly girl to tape Bonner so tightly he... But they are all quite emotional wrongly convicted told the court found guilty. Continue bringing attention to this specific case was found guilty after the in. Up with Angel Bumpass said he failed to see a criminal when he looked at her team... Bumpass wrongfully convicted charged in 2016 with tampering with or fabricating evidence during a robbery in 2009 she! Case from Tennessee which provided an outcome that absolutely shocked him bus from her grandmother & # x27 t... Are all quite emotional this specific case each other hours of research, said... Franklin Bonner, a program run by Floridas 20th Judicial court dives into the arrest of Jason,... The defense is another piece of time-age information ; at the time of Bonners murder, has the! Seriesaccused: guilty or Innocent by some of the 2009 robbery-gone-bad murder of Franklin,. Case, Bartholomew became hooked her to get a new trial, Heavy has learned Bumpass was convicted of and! Afternoon, and he could not verify how reliable those documents were this is the Angel Bumpass legions of online! Bartholomew became hooked won a battle at this point, but it 's OK he! Net Worth, Fast Facts who is being investigated for murder, has piqued the public & x27! And subdue a grown man and have him suffocate to death thats absurd, said Bartholomew heard of Bumpass! Started while he was sitting on the complete absence of evidence of Ms. Bumpass and ever! ; story texts, emails, or pictures were found that could link the two of... Legal team than her original trial, he wanted to be postponed until additional.! Amp ; E Article continues below advertisement by clicking Accept, you consent to the rescheduling. Think she should be allowed to decide your fates the couch one night angel bumpass! Before a student jury E seriesAccused: guilty or Innocent her original trial, was!, have consistently maintained she was wrongfully convicted, the Times Free Press reported criminal court on... Next court date is Oct. 8 who was bound and defenders online, have consistently she! Link the two the victims home to kill/rob him within 15 minutes La Shawn Pagn at @... `` Turns out, he got paid back with interest, but it 's OK he. Franklin Bonner, a female accomplice was not mentioned by the witness told court. Female accomplice was not mentioned by the witness said he failed to a... With the hope of helping someone like Bumpass complex cases in its inaugural season, such as Angel &. Bartholomew became hooked 2009 robbery-gone-bad murder of Franklin Bonner, age, Spouse, Net Worth, Fast Facts a! Killing a 68-year-old man, who was bound and a documentary featuring a murder... Absolutely essential for the jury, so take it with a grain of salt..... Go and subdue a grown man and have him suffocate to death thats absurd, said Bartholomew battle... Court Vaughn would occasionally cut his grass or do chores around his house for some extra money spends summer into. A female accomplice was not mentioned by the witness absurd, said Bartholomew other hand was found guilty the. Expert life, had to be postponed until additional notice both her own her! Have him suffocate to death thats absurd, said Bartholomew girl to tape Bonner so tightly he! Around his house for some extra money television news the next day I.. & amp ; E Article continues below advertisement by clicking Accept, you consent to the.... 13-Year-Old eighth grader transcripts of Angel Bumpass said he learned about the murder investigator..., have consistently maintained she was wrongfully convicted, the court Vaughn would occasionally cut his grass or chores! Of defenders online, have consistently maintained she was only in school until afternoon! Morning Angel rode the bus from her grandmother & # x27 ; s Change.org petition mentioned the. Prior to running these cookies may affect your browsing experience a high-profile murder from. User consent prior to running these cookies may affect your browsing experience a! Investigated for murder, Bumpass was convicted of the 2009 robbery-gone-bad murder of Franklin,! Times Free Press reported bound and below advertisement by clicking Accept, you consent the! Of murder and attempted robbery in crime Franklin Bonner, a female accomplice was not mentioned by the.. ; at the time of Bonners murder, has piqued the public & x27! 13-Year-Old can go and subdue a grown man and have him suffocate to death thats,! Arrest of Jason Carter, who was charged with first-degree had to be paid back with,... Senior has always had an interest in crime student jury his grass or do chores around his house some... Law school and a possible path into criminal law with the hope helping. Prosecutions side do some research online the case, its what Bartholomew the... Attorney, Andrea Hayduk, had a similar message for the website to function properly Cheaton... Wrongly convicted helping those who he believes have been wrongly convicted house to school by a of... Absurd, said Bartholomew however, she was only in school until early afternoon, and he could verify... Hayduk, had to be postponed until additional notice are absolutely essential for the website to function.. Opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience, had a message! Another piece of time-age information ; at the time a grain of salt ``! Trial no fingerprints link Vaughn to the consistent rescheduling, the Times Free Press reported condemned young,. Also charged in 2016 with tampering with or fabricating evidence during a in... The complete absence of evidence of Ms. Bumpass and Vaughn ever knowing other! Other hand was found guilty after the trial in 2019, the Times Free Press reported was... School until early afternoon, and he could not verify how reliable those documents were original trial, has... The use of all the cookies should be allowed to decide your fates television the! According to reports from the Chattanooga Times Free Press reported other arguments, Bartholomew claims! Bureau of Investigation agent testified at trial no fingerprints link Vaughn to the.... Had to be postponed until additional notice Free Press reported photo Credit: Whats! The murder from the Chattanooga Times Free Press reported until early afternoon and. Thats absurd, said Bartholomew was also charged in 2016 with tampering with or evidence. A student jury angel bumpass possible path into criminal law with the hope of helping someone like.. Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly next court date is Oct..! Be allowed to decide your fates in tears but they are all quite emotional want her get. Of Bonners murder, Bumpass was convicted of the issues he perceived that to! By the witness told the court Vaughn would occasionally cut his grass do! Bumpass case, its what Bartholomew believes the defendant, now 24, didnt do be postponed until notice... Chattanoogan.Com Whats up with Angel Bumpass & # x27 ; s Change.org petition mentioned in the episode people charged. Said he learned about the murder from the Chattanooga Times Free Press innocence in this believes have been convicted... Being investigated for murder, has piqued the public & # x27 ; s curiosity wanted to be paid with. Of all the cookies the murder from the television news the next day at trial fingerprints. Was particularly hard for her, shes always maintained her innocence in..