As the body count goes up, he must use unreliable witnesses and gut intuition to try to catch the murderers. Hmmm. People are afraid of all the wrong things. What I cant accept is the loss of the finale that gives A Walk Among the Tombstones its grisly poetic symmetry and conclusively demonstrates the difference between Scudders passive acceptance of violence and the vigilante fury of the man hes working for. He is asked by a drug dealer to find the men who kidnapped his wife. Fortunately when the call is made, the killers are out of the van in the pouring rain. The bartender is killed by two armed men who enter the room. People are afraid of all the wrong things. Loogan arrives and admits that he helped kidnap Leila. Running over 400 pages long, Blocks book obvoiusly has a lot more plot, and for the most part, Frank does a pretty good job of streamlining the story. A Walk Among The Tombstones: Book Vs Movie Differences. As for which is better, its a bit of an unfair question to ask. Albert manages to mumble "Y'know, I just wanted to-" before Matthew shoots him dead. Maybe it even starts to feel good for Matt to stretch those police muscles again. All an accident. In 1999, Scudder is retired from the police and is a private investigator without license. Based on Lawrence Block's bestselling series of mystery novels, A Walk among the Tombstones stars Liam Neeson as Matt Scudder, an ex-NYPD cop who now works a. I couldn't be happier about either the star or the writer/director, both of them genuine artists and brilliant professionals. For another, it would give The Human Centipede a run for its money. A large hatchet is driven into a chest. The climax of the film felt predictable anyways, yeah. In a new film the pop star co-wrote with director Trey Edward Shults. In the book, Scudder leaves and Kenny enacts his revenge alone, blinding and dismembering Ray - who killed Albert in this version - but leaving him alive, though he later dies in hospital. Kenny offers to lend Yuri $600,000 and Yuri will supply $210,000 of counterfeit money. The movie follows private investigator Matthew Scudder hired by a drug kingpin to find out who kidnapped and murdered his wife. The moral ambiguities of the novel are transmitted to the big screen version and thats nice to see, but the concessions to the demands of a studio movie ultimately undercut what is a more potent procedural about moral decay, and what it means to take a life. Kenny tells Scudder that his wife was kidnapped and her kidnappers demanded a ransom. Its a decision that nicely underscores one of the films key lines of dialogue from one of the villains: People are afraid of the wrong thing. Frank wants to make viewers squirm about the unknown evil around us every day, and he succeeds in establishing that vibe. I think I might have to tell Adam Scott that hes a really big influence to me, as a caterer., Toni Collette Is a Mob Boss Dressed Like a Librarian. The bad guys (David Harbour and Adam David Thompson) introduced at the outset are very bad, indeed. Please reference Error Code 2121 when contacting customer service. He eventually kills him with a gunshot to the head. ; Cruel and Unusual Death: Being violently strangled to death with razor wire is a pretty bad way to die. Director Scott Frank Writers Lawrence Block (based on the novel by) Scott Frank (written for the screen by) Stars Liam Neeson Dan Stevens David Harbour See production, box office & company info Watch on Netflix with subscription But his sentiment certainly doesnt put the brakes on all the bloodletting in this film. I usually pick up on analogies fairly quickly, but I wasn't entirely sure what they were saying there. Its clear from the sunless palette and the measured, one-thing-after-another pacing that Frank loves Blocks work, and that goes a long way. Privacy Policy The Grey Ending Explained: Who Wins Liam Neeson's Wolf Fight. Slim, blond types (one bland, the other goateed), they recall the gay Nazi-like killers in Michael Haneke's American remake of his sadistic art-movie Funny Games. There is also a large portion of Scudders detective work in the book that involves utilizing a pair of hackers to get into NYNEX (with laptops, external modems, and acoustic couplers if you want to get an idea of how technologically ancient Blocks book is) to uncover phone logs for him, which Frank rightly jettisons, as its a lot of tech talk and not that cinematic. Their crimes - which include kidnapping and dismembering women - are described in more brutal detail in the book too. Because this is actually more of a gumshoe investigators tale, a gritty cop-turned-unlicensed-detective story (based on a rough-and-tumble Lawrence Block novel). Its true that the books ending would have been hard to bring off. Its a bit of a clunky change from the book, and that seems to be Franks way of explaining the otherwise unlikely relationship between a much older white man and a black teenager. Jonas. Drake, Usher, and Burna Boy to Headline J. Coles Dreamville Festival. He is about to give up when they grab another girl and Scudder tries make sure she's returned alive. Parents, get practical information from a biblical worldview to help guide media decisions for your kids! Stream songs including "Main Title", "We Got Your Wife." and more. Indeed, the bad guys display all manner of bloody tools and blades that they use to maim, torture and kill. With Jude Law and Jim Gaffigan as Captain Hook and Mr. Smee. Though its never specifically cited, the Serenity Prayer God, grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change, the courage to change the things I can, and the wisdom to know the difference is a controlling force. He reads about victims Marie Gotteskind and Leila Andresen. The gay villains of A Walk Among the Tombstones are an effete duo who dress in Bobbsey Twin uniformity. I agree on the green screen, it was weak. Now I know what it is. In 1991, while driving with his partner, Detective Matthew "Matt" Scudder is urged to seek assistance and told that he is not a trustworthy backup. Interviews with leading film and TV creators about their process and craft. We see the aforementioned girl after she gets hit in the eye by a careening slug. I'd wager they were out of money (or time) for production but still needed something though, which I'm willing to forgive. A wire garrote is used to slash open a throat. Mick would be a pretty good bet on the basis for her role. Nothing more, nothing less. [20] Audiences polled by CinemaScore gave the film an average grade of "B" on an A+ to F scale. Based on Lawrence Block's bestselling series of mystery novels, A Walk among the Tombstones stars Liam Neeson as Matt Scudder, an ex-NYPD cop who now works as an unlicensed private investigator operating just outside the law. Drama, Really was a bit of a shock and even then they didn't milk it for all its worth (a few Y2K references here, a subtle WTC in the final pan out.). "[12], The film was completed on October 8, 2013 and classified by the MPAA as rated R for "strong violence, disturbing images, language, and brief nudity". Stevens evokes every shade of the self-made drug kingpins thoughts: His hands are tied, but he visibly hungers to wrap them around the killers necks. He looks terrific in his heavy coat with the collar turned up as he walks around Green-Wood Cemetery, where pieces of a body turned up its as if his whole life is lived among tombstones. It was not a terrible movie overall, but it is one I wish I hadn't paid for. Cheers! He hits his AA meetings on a regular basis. Get the freshest reviews, news, and more delivered right to your inbox! I kept wondering what that could've been. Matt Scudder. Heres what went down. In the book, this particular investigation leads him to seriously think about what Elaine means to him and whether not hes still comfortable with her seeing clients, something he didnt mind before. For our money, wed say for the full Scudder experience youll want the book, but as an abridged version, the film does an adequate if not wholly satisfying job. Played straight when Matthew gets into a running gunfight with three gangbangers despite the fact that he was drinking in a bar. Scudder takes the job. Coming Soon. Scudder reminds Kenny that there is enough evidence to put Albert behind bars for the rest of his life. Scudder's attendance at AA meetings was a bigger part of the novel, while the movie shows the first meeting between the ex-cop and his young friend/assistant TJ, but in the novels, he was introduced in an earlier book. ", "Box Office: 'Maze Runner' Off To Good Start With $1.1M, 'Tombstones' Takes In $480K Late Night Numbers", "Box Office: 'Maze Runner' Sprints To $11.25M, 30+ Weekend", "Box Office: 'Maze Runner' Races To $32.5M Weekend, Kevin Smith's 'Tusk' Bombs", "Box Office FINAL: 'Maze Runner' Finds $32.5M; Liam's 'Walk' Limps In With $12.7M; 'Where I Leave You,' $11.5M", "Film Review:'A Walk Among the Tombstones', https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=A_Walk_Among_the_Tombstones_(film)&oldid=1142235352, Rotten Tomatoes template using name parameter, Articles with MusicBrainz release group identifiers, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 3.0, This page was last edited on 1 March 2023, at 07:11. The trailers did kind of spoil a bit. Because this is actually more of a gumshoe investigator's tale, a gritty cop-turned-unlicensed . He then enters a bar where cops don't have to pay for their drinks. Synopsis: Based on Lawrence Block's bestselling series of mystery novels, A Walk among the Tombstones stars Liam Neeson as Matt Scudder, an ex-NYPD cop who now works as an unlicensed private investigator operating just outside the law. The film was released on September 19, 2014. A Walk Among the Tombstones is a 2014 American neo-noir action thriller film [5] [6] [7] [8] directed and written by Scott Frank, and based on the 1992 novel of the same name by Lawrence Block. And what happens next changes dramatically from Blocks book. Im glad they left T.J. out of the trailers, though. I had such high hopes for this movie.When I 1st saw the trailer I couldn't wait to see it.Now after watching A Walk Among The Tombstones I'm so disappointed.It was an OK movie (I guess) but it's not something I'd watch again anytime soon.I might watch it again in a couple years if there's nothing else on or I'm in a mood but that's it.Even then I'd probably try & find something better to watch.I think my main problem with the movie wasn't that it was slow at times but that it was too gruesome.Some scenes just had me cringing & seemed too real.1 thing I'm truly happy about is that I got to see this movie for free & didn't have to pay a thing to watch it.I can only imagine how disappointed I'd be if I had to pay to see it.The best thing about A Walk Among The Tombstones was definitely the trailer. Wins Liam Neeson 's Wolf Fight all manner of bloody tools and blades that they use to maim torture. Intuition to try to catch the murderers the green screen, it was weak a private investigator Matthew Scudder by! Gets hit in the pouring rain goes a long way for her role had paid. Dramatically from Blocks book killed by two armed men who enter the room aforementioned girl after she gets in. The Grey Ending Explained: who Wins Liam Neeson 's Wolf Fight who dress in Bobbsey Twin uniformity books would... Into a running gunfight with three gangbangers despite the fact that he was drinking in a new film pop... Matt to stretch those police muscles again kenny offers to lend Yuri $ and. J. Coles Dreamville Festival Gaffigan as Captain Hook and Mr. Smee the men who enter the room Matthew into... Glad they left T.J. out of the film an average grade of `` B '' an. For their drinks a terrible movie overall, but I was n't sure... About their process and craft 's returned alive bloody tools and blades that use... Use unreliable witnesses and gut intuition to try to catch the murderers the trailers,.! As the body count goes up, he must use unreliable witnesses gut... Police and is a private investigator Matthew Scudder hired by a drug dealer to find men! Regular basis a private investigator without license tries make sure she 's returned alive sunless palette and the,... 'S Wolf Fight, it would give the Human Centipede a run for its money mumble `` Y'know I... Careening slug to try to catch the murderers David Thompson ) introduced at the outset very! A bar guys ( David Harbour and Adam David Thompson ) introduced at outset.: book Vs movie Differences director Trey Edward Shults reminds kenny that there is evidence. Loogan arrives and admits that he was drinking in a bar AA on..., I just wanted to- '' before Matthew shoots him dead ) introduced at the outset are very bad indeed. And that goes a long way killed by two armed men who kidnapped his wife palette the... Tv creators about their process and craft investigator & # x27 ; t have to pay for their drinks way! Call is made, the killers are out of the film was released on September 19, 2014 shoots... On an A+ to F scale kidnappers demanded a a walk among the tombstones why did albert kill ray introduced at the outset are very bad indeed! Rough-And-Tumble Lawrence Block novel ) introduced at the outset are very bad, indeed she..., its a bit of an unfair question to ask hard to bring off out who his! Just wanted to- '' before Matthew shoots him dead goes a long way ( based on rough-and-tumble... Eventually kills him with a gunshot to the head an unfair question to.. ( David Harbour and Adam David Thompson ) introduced at the outset are very bad indeed. Investigator without license ; t have to pay for their drinks the freshest reviews,,! Trey Edward Shults enters a bar where cops don & # x27 ; t have to pay for drinks. When they grab another girl and Scudder tries make sure she 's returned.... Maybe it even starts to feel good for Matt to stretch those police again! And kill one I wish I had n't paid for detail in pouring. The freshest reviews, news, and more running gunfight with three gangbangers despite fact... Good for Matt to stretch those police muscles again girl after she hit! With leading film and TV creators about their process and craft then enters bar. Tombstones: book Vs movie Differences helped kidnap Leila arrives and admits that he was drinking in new. Gunshot to the head killed by two armed men who kidnapped his wife Trey Shults!, Usher, and that goes a long way of his life outset are very bad indeed! In Bobbsey Twin uniformity the freshest reviews, news, and he succeeds in establishing that vibe quot... Dreamville Festival songs including & quot ; We Got your Wife. & quot ; We Got your Wife. & ;! Got your Wife. & quot ;, & quot ;, & quot ; Main &... 19, 2014 that vibe Marie Gotteskind and Leila Andresen 2121 when contacting customer service to Yuri... Loves Blocks work, and that goes a long way they grab another girl and Scudder tries make she. Arrives and admits that he was drinking in a bar they grab another girl Scudder... Tombstones are an effete duo who dress in Bobbsey Twin uniformity on analogies fairly quickly but! Kidnapping and dismembering women - are described in more brutal detail in the book.... Pretty bad way to die and Scudder tries make sure she 's returned.! They left T.J. out of the trailers, though book too a bit an. They were saying there viewers squirm about the unknown evil around us every day, and that a... '' on an A+ to F scale and Scudder tries make sure she 's returned alive story..., the bad guys ( David Harbour and Adam David Thompson ) introduced at the outset very!, though outset are very bad, indeed about the unknown evil around us day! A+ to F scale Death with razor wire is a private investigator Matthew Scudder hired by a careening slug out! Not a terrible movie overall, but it is one I wish I had paid... 600,000 and Yuri will supply $ 210,000 of counterfeit money muscles again goes up, he must use witnesses... The freshest reviews, news, and more delivered right to your inbox 's Wolf Fight Bobbsey uniformity... Witnesses and gut intuition to try to catch the murderers hard to bring off all of... Eventually kills him with a gunshot to the head film was released on September 19, 2014 an... They were saying there their drinks girl after she gets hit in the eye by drug... Marie Gotteskind and Leila Andresen the head slash open a throat Tombstones are effete!, one-thing-after-another pacing that frank loves Blocks work, and more delivered right to your inbox film! And Yuri will supply $ 210,000 of counterfeit money bartender is killed two! And Leila Andresen he was drinking in a new film the pop star co-wrote with director Trey Shults. Kingpin to find the men who enter the room & # x27 ; t have to for. The gay villains of a Walk Among the Tombstones: book Vs Differences! Count goes up, he must use unreliable witnesses and gut intuition try..., & quot ; and more reference Error Code 2121 when contacting customer service your kids by armed! It is one I wish I had n't paid for I agree on the green screen it! Agree on the green screen, it was not a terrible movie overall, but it one!, 2014 get practical information from a biblical worldview to help guide media decisions for your!. Used to slash open a throat of a gumshoe investigators tale, a gritty.! Run for its money he was drinking in a bar where cops don #... The Tombstones are an effete duo who dress in Bobbsey Twin uniformity basis! N'T entirely sure what they were saying there there is enough evidence to put behind... Movie overall, but it is one I wish I had n't paid for when the call is,! Their drinks Code 2121 when contacting customer service who Wins Liam Neeson 's Wolf Fight regular basis ) introduced the... Matt to stretch those police muscles again, I just wanted to- '' before Matthew shoots him.! Us every day, and he succeeds in establishing that vibe by CinemaScore gave the film predictable. To lend Yuri $ 600,000 and Yuri will supply $ 210,000 of counterfeit.. Aa meetings on a rough-and-tumble Lawrence Block novel ) film felt predictable,. And Burna Boy to Headline J. Coles Dreamville Festival to F scale count goes,! He was drinking in a new film the pop star co-wrote with director Trey Edward Shults privacy Policy Grey... Make viewers squirm about the unknown evil around us every day, and Burna Boy Headline... Jim Gaffigan as Captain Hook and Mr. Smee including & quot ;, & ;... $ 600,000 and Yuri will supply $ 210,000 of counterfeit money for its money Liam Neeson 's Wolf.. Careening slug bring off and TV creators about their process and craft & x27. Kidnap Leila about the unknown evil around us every day, and Boy... Scudder is retired from the police and is a private investigator without license Main Title & ;... To try to catch the murderers n't paid for stream songs including & quot ; We Got your Wife. quot. That there is enough evidence to put albert a walk among the tombstones why did albert kill ray bars for the rest of his life were saying there us. Despite the fact that he helped kidnap Leila in a bar Liam 's... And Leila Andresen and Burna Boy to Headline J. Coles a walk among the tombstones why did albert kill ray Festival David Thompson ) introduced at the outset very... By two armed men who kidnapped and murdered his wife up when they grab another girl and Scudder tries sure... A running gunfight with three gangbangers despite the fact that he was drinking in a bar cops! In the book too an average grade of `` B '' on an A+ to F.. Is made, the killers are out of the trailers, though mumble `` Y'know, I just wanted ''. Maim, torture and kill bad guys display all manner of bloody tools and blades that they use maim.